The Defamation and Assassination of Ms. Lauryn Hill

Jul 29, 2012 13 Comments by

I helped kill Lauryn Hill, and I regret it. In truth, we all let her die, even as she fights for her life, we simply are allowing one of our most prolific people to be eaten by a system she has tirelessly attempted to fight with her weapon of choice, a voice.

Though most of us will never understand her movements, her soul is parallel to those who have chosen to die on their feet rather than live on their knees. Unlike most of us, who prefer a good beat, a good piece of ass, a great weave and a promotion, and we’re good, the path she has taken is not for the weak-minded or weak-spirited. Lauryn lives a bipolor existence — on one hand, she is adored like a Goddess — and on the other she is perpetually defamed.

When I heard that little punkass kid from Mindless Behavior tell the most crass joke at the BET Awards regarding Lauryn Hill’s tax issues with the IRS and the looming possibility of her serving time for admitting to not filing, I turned off BET, a station I had sworn years ago not to watch.

And though the crowd booed, I couldn’t believe how BET kept that rank comment, or the writers even wrote that tasteless piece of bullshit. I know that, that overly greased kid didn’t understand how much he spat on a shoulder that carried him, but for BET to place that jab on a pubescent, greasy haired, overly boyscaped creature was punkass in itself. (Shout out to Beyonce for attempting to correct the wrong. And another fuck you to the management of Mindless Behavior [appropriate name] for not vetting the tweet that called her a ‘girl’ in their apology)

Ironically, just a few years ago, BET was begging Lauryn Hill to perform on its stage, as Talib Kweli points out in his ode to Lauryn in “Ms. Hill”.

When I heard Lauryn might be incarcerated for past taxes this week, I was floored. It is an eerie reminiscent of something we have seen before. Not talking about Wesley Snipes—though he is rolled into the political, social trappings of articulating humanity on his own terms; I am thinking more about Marcus Garvey, who was jailed and deported for frivolous charges of mail fraud, or Muhammad Ali, who was imprisoned for refusing to fight in Vietnam.

It is disgusting how so many, and let’s start with the music industry, revere Lauryn’s work like spiritual tomes, yet are mum to come to her aid, or support her. The statement is simple, “Lauryn is right.” The industry is a vampire, and subsists on the blood of artists who are sacrificed on stage, in studios, on video shoots, and at contract signings.

For years I defended Lauryn, listened to her music, and never wavered from my steadfast loyalty and support for a black woman who was attempting to be free and live on her own terms under a rubric that simply does not allow folk to grow and evolve.

I held on to my sister, and the legacy she left, that is still light-years ahead of hip hop, pop, and the music industry. Lauryn used her platform to enlighten, empower, and heal; yet she, didn’t even understand the depths of the power she flexed and the people she still touches with the soul of her essence.

She went against the Pope. Nuff said. When CNN would not even put a 20 second sound bite that exposed the sex scandal still rocking the Catholic church to the Protestant church, Lauryn sang her revolution at the Vatican.

For the record, Obama would not dare, but he’s a politician right, who must move with the savvy of a refined leader. Hmph.

Lauryn represents a mainstream black artist who is damn near extinct. Like Harry Belafonte, Sammy Davis, Jr., Lena Horne, Ossie Davis, Ruby Dee, she took notes from history and used her voice for social issues and Civil Rights.

Unfortunately, she does not have a circle of contemporaries who stand with her, unflinchingly. She has a crew of cowards, who fled when their money was threatened and the threat of them losing favor in the industry began to magnify.

Nonetheless, Lauryn Hill is transparent in a journey we all have to take, in the painful search for love. Evident in an on-and-off again abusive relationship with the father of most, or all of her children, Rohan Marley, Lauryn illuminates that she bleeds like all of us, and does dumb shit.

And while Lauryn looks at the possibility of being jailed and making arrangements for the care of her children, Rohan Marley is planning his third marriage.

We all have questions through the years of Lauryn’s silence. Answers we must all have to come up with ourselves. Though I have heard of her struggles with labels, for me, it was much deeper. Her punishment is for the fact that she did not give certain institutions access to her innermost sanctum, her soul.

They did not have access to her children, her relationships, nor her creative process. She, in all her black woman glory, told them what they could listen to, and how they could listen. For that, the only thing they could plug on her was from a past, bitter lover, who once had access to her being.

Rather than explain the complexities of an entangled love affair, of which both sides did dirt, Wyclef Jean did what most immature, jilted ex-lovers do, and in particular when it comes to pointing the finger at the woman, he claimed Lauryn was simply “crazy.”

Ahhh, how easy is that. To write someone off as a crazy and insane.

As Dave Chappelle brilliantly pointed out after his hiatus of Hollywood’s manipulative, demeaning, and sadistic culture, when they call you crazy it is a “dismissive” tactic that is used to discredit and silence the very credible and intellectually astute articulations of people who were willing to speak out against a machine that has consumed and spit out prophets and activists, and simply good folk who could not be exploited any longer.

And as I watched a cable station I have long abhorred for its narrow content and coonery leanings, I witnessed another blow to a sister who may not be a saint, but definitely is being crucified.

email

Comments

comments

Culture, Entertainment, Gender, Race, Uncategorized

About the author

Eco.Soul.Intellectual is a Los Angeles native living in the NYC Metro area. A former print journalist turned blog junkie, Eco.Soul is an adjunct professor, cultural-social-political critic, and traveler who is still trying to figure this shit out.
  • Val

    I’ve always been amazed (and deeply saddened) at how so many people seemed to take glee in making fun of Lauryn for the last several years. It just goes to show you that the admiration of so-called fans stops the second you don’t follow their rules of what a star should act or look like.

    Btw, Muhammad Ali was never imprisoned. He was convicted but remained free while he appealed his conviction. And ultimately his conviction was overturned.

    http://commentarybyvalentina.wordpress.com/

    .

    • http://twitter.com/Coffey0072 Coffey

      re: “It just goes to show you that the admiration of so-called fans stops the
      second you don’t follow their rules of what a star should act or look
      like.”

      – Exactly… and that expectation definitely extends to the industry and the puppeteers behind the scenes. It’s nasty a nasty, soul-sucking political game. It always annoyed me when people insisted Lauryn came undone and had a mental “breakdown” when it was obvious (at least to me) that she was taking control of her own image and expunging all of the toxic “industry” people from her life. I don’t care what critics say… Her Unplugged album, as raw and unfinished as it was, was awesome, and told a compelling story if folks had actually listened to what she was saying about why she stayed away from the business and secluded herself.

      • http://www.facebook.com/ecosoul.intellectual Ecosoul Intellectual

        Gratzi. I think people have also gotten Hill fatigue around her incognito stature in an age where the average celeb is tweeting, FB posting, instagraming, dining @ Mr. Chow’s for paparazzi, etc.

    • http://www.facebook.com/ecosoul.intellectual Ecosoul Intellectual

      Val, though Ali was never imprisoned in an industrial complex, he was stripped and forbidden to fight like house arrest. Thanks for adding the clarity for folks who don’t the story.

  • http://theurbanpolitico.com/ Shady Grady

    But what does any of this have to do with her not paying her taxes? She didn’t file tax returns for three years. The IRS notices something like that.

  • http://www.facebook.com/ecosoul.intellectual Ecosoul Intellectual

    Shady Grady, your dismissive attitude is exactly what keeps the wheels of injustice turning. Never once did I say she was innocent of not filing taxes. And filing federal taxes is such a sham anyway, but that’s another debate. However, a corporation can have offshore banking and never file one US tax return; and truth be told, quite a few people do not, but are afforded some type of resolution or payoff. My point being, Hill is a target for not playing along. There had to be something that she did. She didn’t fuck kids. She wasn’t a crack head, so the taxes thing stuck. It is a worn out, but still effective tactic that has people co-signing to injustice and unfairness while sealing their own doom.

    • http://theurbanpolitico.com/ Shady Grady

      Are you even remotely serious? If you don’t even file tax returns that is a red flag to the IRS. If you have, as she did, income over the three years of 1.6 million, and don’t pay taxes you’re gonna go to prison/probation, just like Leona “only the little people pay taxes” Helmsley.

      There are ways to legally reduce or avoid taxes. Not filing and spewing forth mumbo-jumbo about being controlled by the military industrial complex is not one of them. Perhaps she suffers from depression?

      In any event, depressed or not, you’ve gotta file returns and pay your taxes. If you don’t want to do that that’s your right but don’t be surprised when men with guns come to take you someplace unpleasant for a while.

      Arguing that someone else might have gotten away with something is the same thing the speeder doing 90 MPH in a 60 MPH zone tells the cop when he gets pulled over. Yes, the cop can’t catch everyone but that has nothing to do with the fact that you were breaking the law.

      • http://www.tracyreneejones.com Tracy Renee Jones

        No, she didn’t pay her taxes….and so…but strange that an otherwise law abiding citizens, whose lively hood includes raising several children (if not supporting family and relatives as people do in regular life) should go to jail with no get out of jail free card.

        The Feds are WAYYYYYY more concerned with wealthy non-tax payers to pay those back taxes, plus fees, plus fines, plus interest..plus….Mo Money Mo Money.

        True, the average person is worth a pretty penny in jail, however, the usual remedy to this situation is to have the person pay restitution, not jail time where their income (future taxes…) will be compromised. Makes no sense, see…

        Two, the article is about how no one gives a fuck about Lauren Hill because she’s not a stage monkey, media whore willing to sell her soul to stay ‘relevant’ with people who don’t GIF. Her old music is still amazing, her new music may not be for her old fan base, she’s not the first artist to change lanes, and lose some fans.

        Uh, yeah… There’s always the option to jail a person that broke the law, that’s the point, on the greater scheme of things this could be a simple incident of a person of color with clout and what happens on tonight’s episode of Justice Gone Wild….you know how we do… *drops the gavel like its hot*

        • http://theurbanpolitico.com/ Shady Grady

          Ask Irwin Schiff about whether or not the government is serious about putting people in jail who give the government a middle finger by not filing returns and not paying taxes. Black, white, staid establishment, would be revolutionary, you’re gonna pay taxes.

          Hill is not the first artist to fall out of favor and won’t be the last. I doubt it but 20 years from now people may be talking about her great genius. Who knows? But that has nothing to do with why she’s in trouble. Ja Rule,Heidi Fleiss, Ronald Isley and Richard Hatch went to prison for not paying taxes. I don’t think they were targeted because of their revolutionary stances. They were targeted because they didn’t pay taxes.

          The point of sending people to jail is precisely to make an example so that anyone who is idiotic enough not to file for years will have the possible example of Hill or past example of Helmsley in their mind and think twice before doing something so reckless.

      • http://www.facebook.com/ecosoul.intellectual Ecosoul Intellectual

        You know what Shady Grady, you are the upstanding citizen that they wish we all could be. Live by the book, die by the book. Literally. While laws are bent and construed to fit the likings of those who have created an unbalanced and inequitable economic landscape, they love it when someone who gets the pennies defends the same system that throws chump change. My friend, if there is any mumbo-jumbo, Celtic cauldron spell binding ash spewing, it is from your logic. When you are ready to acknowledge that these laws are made to benefit few, while punish most, then, perhaps we can talk.

  • Uluru Sasa

    If people are going to be so critical of a single person who does not pay her taxes that only equal 1.6 million, those same people need to be ready to be just as critical of corporations who are not paying their taxes (and havent for years) that add up to 10s of billions of dollars.

  • Deb

    This is some beautiful, “decolonial love” (http://www.salon.com/writer/paula_m_l_moya/) for a sister who — certainly deserves it. Thank you for this.

  • E

    “Lauryn lives a bipolor existence — on one hand, she is adored like a Goddess — and on the other she is perpetually defamed.” Like all black women, Lauryn is stuck in a paradigm she didn’t create, in which no black woman is allowed to be fully human.

Facebook

Get the Facebook Likebox Slider Pro for WordPress
Google+