Miriam Carey, Unforgettable and Unnecessary? - Madness & Reality

Miriam Carey, Unforgettable and Unnecessary?

Oct 06, 2013 7 Comments by

The name Miriam Carey is one we should never forget. The woman at the center of what is looking more and more like yet another potential case of excessive police force is just as dead as Jonathan Ferrell, another name we should never forget.  Mr. Ferrell shot dead and killed after an automobile accident by police who were called by a frightened woman who’s door he knocked ostensibly seeking help after climbing out of the car he had been driving that was involved in an accident.

Miriam Carey – is a name that should never be forgotten. So far what little information that has been put out centers around her job  as a dental hygienist and  where she lived in Brooklyn and apparently Connecticut. There have been vague statements about her possibly suffering from Post-partum depression as well as her being on some form of medication that might be psychotropic and that she was in the process of being weaned off of.  Comments about mental illness as a root cause to this have been thrown around however  the question in that instance would remain — was there no other way for Miriam Carey to get help or for her situation to be resolved aside from the way it turned out?

As the investigation is ongoing not much is being said by local DC law enforcement aside from a press conference given on the evening that the events occurred. One interview that was given by the sisters of Miriam Carey indicated that they had no idea that their sister was headed towards DC and that they couldn’t speak to any motivation on her part to explain any part of the actions that led to her death.

The one thing the sisters did say is that they are not understanding why she had to be killed to be stopped.

There are a lot of questions on this case that need to be answered, some of which never may be answered.  Did Miriam Carey actually try to ram the barricades at the White House to gain entry? What ACTUALLY happened at the checkpoint where this all started. Who if anyone did she speak to the day that this tragic event took place. What did her day look like? Did she just get up get dressed dress her child and drive to DC? What is the protocol for dealing with attempted vehicle breaches to the White House perimeter or any other government office in DC? Local law enforcement in DC have indicated that Ms. Carey was a danger because she was using her vehicle as a weapon  and that justified the use of deadly force – was there NO other way to stop or prevent Miriam Carey’s vehicle from proceeding any further beyond the initial engagement at the White House Checkpoint?

Due in part to our morbid fascination with “reality” based TV shows, there is plenty of footage around to show high speed car chases and the response by law enforcement which usually does not end with the vehicle being shot up by law enforcement unless they are returning gun fire. The main question in most minds that MUST be answered is was firing upon the vehicle the ONLY way this situation could have been ended?

The other more burning question of why this happened will probably never be answered. I sincerely doubt that Ms. Carey left a manifesto behind explaining her actions and plan to visit DC.

Miriam Careys sisters

Miriam Careys sisters

The one thing that is known right now is that a woman with a child in the car was subjected to gun fire by law enforcement in her attempts to get away and that she injured two law enforcement officers in her attempts to get away from people who were shooting at her. The rest of the strands of this story have yet to be woven into something that is recognizable or palatable.

I would sincerely HOPE that the level of interest shown to inane matters such as the latest installment of nighttime soap opera fare, or whether or not twerking is part of black culture is shown in this case. I would hope that support and interest in this case would transcend interest in cases where individuals who have been duly tried and convicted and sentenced in accordance with state laws and guidelines but wish to now use the specter and notoriety of stand your ground and domestic violence to cover bad choices made by a person who lived a messy life and as we all do had to deal with the consequences of her choices.

I am waiting to see if the “sisterhood” is going to rally around the sisters of Miriam Carey and demand justice or a full and thorough investigation. I am waiting to see if the NAACP and the usual suspects are going to march and rally for justice on behalf of Ms. Carey.

I guess as long as it doesn’t conflict with the next episode of whatever salacious and or reality based television event that requires the attention of those masses.

Someone might want to inform  them that It doesn’t get any realer than this.

email

Comments

comments

Gender

About the author

Continuing on life's journey on the road less traveled, currently a non-tradional student pursuing a degree at Claflin University, writing book reviews for the Claflin Panther, Education editor at Twitchange.com owner of The Good Black Woman blog/website, IT and Cloud Services Consultant, digital graphics enthusiast, writer of prose, articles and assorted means of written expression. You can follow me on Twitter @Blkphoenix66
  • Katherine McChesney

    Carey was suffering from schizophrenia. She thought obama was after her. She was violent, crashing her car into barriers. She was warned. She didn’t stop when the officers told her to. She endangered her child. Her family knew she was mentally ill and they did nothing to protect her child from her illness. This is a sad story but the officers had no choice but to shoot her. Her family is part to blame for this.

    • beattitudes66

      Don’t believe everything you hear on the news….

  • http://lets-be-clear.blogspot.com/ Deb_C

    Beattitudes56…got this update today from a friend — “Report: Miriam Carey was fleeing on foot when shot by police” http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/359765#tab=comments&sc=0%23ixzz2h3pDmUIf#ixzz2h46BMGsR

    Thanks for writing about Miriam with some sense and a critical eye. I did too here: http://lets-be-clear.blogspot.com/2013/10/the-white-supremacy-collective-still.html

    They had all the choice in the world NOT to shoot her. Your other commenter can put the blame on everyone else but on whom it belongs — I will not. People, women especially, willing to sit back and watch unarmed women be gunned down in cold blood make me ill. We live in a violent, racist police state that keeps getting more violent, more racist and more “police” every day because there are so many afraid people who encourage and applaud it.

    I pray her daughter, her sisters and her mother are able to get enough support to get to the bottom of this disaster and those who shot her down like an animal in the street are punished to the full extent of the law. Sister, let us rally around all those sisters in her family! I’ll do anything I can to help. No need to look for the “usual suspects on this one — our society, above all else is patriarchal. No matter the race, female lives still fall far below males of any age, IMHO.

    (P.S. I’m SC born and bred and am hoping to move back there soon! Glad your journey took you to Claflin and I hope you’re getting all you seek as you continue it! Will check your blog out real soon.)

    • beattitudes66

      Thanks for the feedback and also taking time to read this piece. Those claiming specific mental illness diagnosis need to be careful, there has not been any clear statement as to what she was diagnosed with by an actual medical professional. I do not take into account what people thought she might have (including her family) because they would only know what she told them and because of HIPPA laws would not have actual information on what she was being treated for. I am just so disgusted that this story is being spun (away) as though nothing to see here just another “off: person that went off. It just disgusts me that you can’t even say she was shot down like a dog because they would not have shot a dog down like that. IF she was exiting the car and was shot pray tell what specific threat did she pose at that time which warranted the officers opening fire and gunning her down in front of her child? And this is is a story being relegated and spun off into obscurity. Really?

      • http://lets-be-clear.blogspot.com/ Deb_C

        You’re welcome, Sister.

        “I am just so disgusted that this story is being spun (away) as though nothing to see here just another “off: person that went off. It just disgusts me that you can’t even say she was shot down like a dog because they would not have shot a dog down like that.”

        I’m disgusted as well, but I see you give them too much credit: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/07/01/police-shoot-dog_n_3530990.html

        “IF she was exiting the car and was shot pray tell what specific threat did she pose at that time which warranted the officers opening fire and gunning her down in front of her child?”

        No “IF” about it, and last time I looked, unarmed folk pose no threat at all. Hard as it is to fathom, giving murderers the benefit of the doubt only leads to more murders. Not many are writing about the story because they know it was murder. Those who know and justify it, would just rather it went away quietly into some dark night. Really.

        • beattitudes66

          Sadly I would have to agree with you in that those who could and should be having something to say are choosing the easy way out, that is to look the other way rather than speak truth to power. This is why bloggers are so darn important right now because no one at all would be talking about this case if there weren’t bloggers writing about it.

          • http://lets-be-clear.blogspot.com/ Deb_C

            “This is why bloggers are so darn important right now because no one at all would be talking about this case if there weren’t bloggers writing about it.”

            That’s the truth! It’s like it never even happened right? I appreciate your writing about it that’s for sure.

            Checked out your site, some beautiful art and poetry in tribute to us! :-) Do you know of a poetess whose written anything about us being nurturers — for our children? Their children? All civilization? Working on a Breast Cancer Awareness Month project with my brother. Let me know if you do, okay?

Facebook

Get the Facebook Likebox Slider Pro for WordPress
Google+