Why My White Friends Don’t Live in Post-Racial America: Addressing Privilege and Microaggressions

May 24, 2012 34 Comments by

Perhaps one of the highlights of my 2012 thus far was the explosion that the internet put on the shit certain people say. I’m not speaking of the issues in North Carolina (because there are obviously plenty), nor the conspiracy of the birth of Beyonce and Jay Z’s daughter. What I mean is the avalanche that swept youtube earlier in the year in examining privilege and microaggressions. Famously, “Shit White Girls Say…To Black Girls” Parts 1 and 2 in all of its brilliance caused an explosion of videos, from the frivolous to the righteous, from women of color about the shit white girls say to them as a result of their privilege and unexamined (by them) prejudices. Brilliant Chescaleigh spawned several other brazen and bright feminist videos by other women of color, including but not limited to:

Shit White Girls Say to Latinas, Shit White Girls Say… To Brown (Desi/Indian) Girls, Shit White Girls Say…to Arab Girls, Shit White Girls Say To Asian Girls, and many other stellar vids addressing white girl privilege.

I thought back to this incredible hullabaloo, as I often do, when I spend time with some of my white comrades. While I tend to think of myself as a “one (wo)man wolf pack“, I often find myself spending time as a growing-older twenty-something with young, white professionals that I may have worked with at a certain point. I’ve oft found that since I have experience in such progressive fields, my white friends and I have much in common. For that reason, it baffles me when I hear them say things about people of color that makes me aware of their lack of ownership of their privilege. Of course, this is often the cause for the divide in feminism between white women and women of color.

I think that a rift began in mine and my good friend’s relationship when I was expressing my previous partner’s Haitian-Namibian lineage and she chuckled and mentioned the words ‘voodoo’ and ‘Africans’ in the same sentence, as if she were completely unaware of my brown skin. And there were similar comments, not on the same level or time, but here and there: “I can totally say this next comment, because my relative is (insert ethnicity here)” and “ZOMG I let my boyfriend listen to this song ‘The Motto’ by Drake and showed him a hip-hop dance, but he told me that I wasn’t ghetto enough” and “I listen to hip-hop all the time; everyone tells me I’m Black on the inside.” It exhausts me, and even more exhausting is that I’ve become less of the privilege-and-racism-attacking-machine hotshot that I once was. I used to be quite adept at breaking down these thought patterns, whatever the cost, and I’ve become challenged at it — especially when the subject delivering these microaggressions are current colleagues.

I compare the microaggressions based on social and cultural misguidance and, well..privilege, to objectification in that, while the person delivering the underhanded remarks may not find them to be so, these comments are often an attempt to singularly define an individual or group by some attribute, negative or otherwise. I was once told by a very brilliant friend of mine that he believes objectification to be an irritation; however, while objectification (and these microaggressions that are comprised mainly of words that may not be injurious) is small in comparison to the many other battles we are faced with in our separate and intersecting marginalized communities, we have to find a balance in battling privilege, objectification, and the like because they are detrimental to identity and progress. I’m tired of white girls telling me they’re going to tanning beds because they’re ‘trynabe’ like me. Cut that shit out.

I’m tired of white people throwing ethnic-themed parties with 40s, fried chicken and watermelon. I’m tired of children having to go to school to homework with racially inappropriate questions. And white parents who allow their kid to dress in blackface when he’s in character as Dr. Martin Luther (the) King, Jr.

What says you, readers? What is the most honest way to address privilege short of cursing out colleagues and friends? How do we examine the overlapping oppression among our peer activists who, apparently, are unaware (or unabashed) of the other forms of white privilege they possess?

Comments

comments

Black History, Children, Culture, Post Racial Society, Race Matters, Social Engineering, White Privilege

About the author

"Livication” is a mix of the words “live” and “dedication”, and is an important concept how I live. I've been dubbed a post-modern hippie. I can come at you on some old school revolution, or kick it with my contemporaries. I am a social butterfly (but also a square peg), Blacktivist, LGBTQ (any/all civil rights) advocate, womanist, feminist, and Black woman. I'm mouthy and passionate; difficult to silence. An abstract thinker and self-defined. An unapologetic fantastic disaster. Calm like a bomb.
  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

    White Privilege is nothing more than the same in-group racial preference ALL races have for their own members.
    I acknowledge yours. You’ll acknowledge mine.
    Have a nice day.

    • Anonymous

      White privilege: reading the term ‘white privilege’ in the title of the post and commenting on what you think the author meant, instead of what the written text says.

      • PCNarcissiticMadness

        White Privilege to you is someone else not being hypersensitive and meeting the everchanging demands of how you want people to think, act and speak on any given topic.   As you just proved above.    

        Someday you should think about Black privilege,. The number one that comes to my mind is thinking you have the right to be eternally offended and appeased moreso than anyone else.  And no one has a right to be who they are, proud of who they are, enjoy who they are without putting your tender feelings ahead of their own.   What makes you think that will do anything but make people have to work harder just to engage you on your stringent terms, eventually winding up with your interacting only with those who have no choice or those that  enjoy abuse.  

        Ridiculous dramatic terms are one further example.  Overlapping oppression – Reallly for noticing that a specific group is well known to buy 40′s, eat chicken……is it a lie? No? How is observing this oppressive?  White women like xxxxxxx, if you observe that, are they oppressed?  It isn’t oppression if you are embarassed for whatever insecure reasons of someone noticing and commenting on behaviours. The answer isn’t to Oppress them and demand they censor speech, if you are embarassed, change the behaviour. If not, embrace them fully but recognize what you allow me to say without an argument defines you , not me.

        • Anonymous

          See below comment.

  • Reggie

    Where in the hell does this shit come from?!?

    • Anonymous

      What, privilege? Usually, it’s the covert, ‘I-didn’t-know-that-was-inappropriate’, ‘I-didn’t-see-anything-wrong-with-that’, ‘I-have-a-Black-friend’ sort of racism/sexism/cissexism/heteronormativism/ableism… etc. I’m not claiming that it’s always intentional. I don’t think it matters whether or not it is, though. The issue comes in how we address it.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

        We address it by ignoring your bitching about it.

        • Anonymous

          The problem is that the ones who maintain the privilege aren’t the objects of the offensives. It clearly doesn’t matter to you as an individual, as your comments have proven unproductive; however, the people who are already marginalized as a result of your privilege (and both latent and blatant racism) have a duty to respond in some fashion. 
          Thank you for exhibiting your privilege and proving my point. :)

          • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

            I’m “marginalized” by not being included in Black Privilege. Where is your moral outrage about that?
            Should I sue?
            Should I care?

          • Anonymous

            I’m not certain that I’m up for reparte with a person who is obviously dismissing any claims of privilege and racism. Unfortunately, it would not be in the interest of either of us considering your definition of marginalization (versus the rest of the world’s). Your comments are intended to spark emotion, and you’re dismissing the entire post (which you still have yet to respond to, by the way) in a passive aggressive manner that is not based in fact.

          • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

            You have your privileges, I have mine.
            You deny your own racism and privilege but hype mine. Welcome to America, we’re all equal to like or not like. 

          • http://heavyarmor.wordpress.com/ Heavy Armor

            Then maybe you can answer this question for me:

            What “privileges” do Black People that you feel are denied to you as a White Person?

            Please be specific.

          • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

            Blacks have nothing I want. I’m satisfied with my in-group preference of White privilege. You should be with yours.

          • http://heavyarmor.wordpress.com/ Heavy Armor

            In other words, you can’t answer the question.

            Typical.

          • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

            .

            I answered the question, you simply ignored it.

            .

          • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002965779125 Ryan Malcolm Jonny

            The ability to organize however they want without being called racists for excluding anyone.
            The ability to degrade and dehumanize other races(especially whites)with racial epithets that are accepted because they are supposedly ‘just words’ that are ‘silly’.
            The ability to not have the negative aspects of their people’s history DEFINE their people’s history.

          • Prod_gen

            Perhaps you’d be happier in Africa.

          • Anonymous

            You know, you’re right. I’m sure that moving to Africa will make you a lot less racist. (Your comment proves my post.)

  • http://rippdemup.com/ RiPPa

    So about that “white privilige” thingy, check out the blackface in this video:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=YDhf9qwiA34 

    • Anonymous

      Interesting. I think that there’s a lot more to that than mere blackface, but it’s certainly a component. More irritating than anything to hear this woman proclaim that she went to an ivy league school and took out no loans to study music and now can’t find a job. Meh.

  • http://twitter.com/Coffey0072 Coffey

    The trollish comments on here are classic derails and ad hominems, often used by people who operate in White Privilege. People who operate in White Privilege can’t stand having their White supremacy challenged, so they resort to classic derails…

    http://www.derailingfordummies.com/menu.html

    … and make up terms like “Black privilege” because they want to be able to freely perpetuate racial stereotypes and operate in ignorance. You all have more than proved  the points @Livication:disqus outlined in her article… to the letter.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

      .

      Racially insensitive? Check

      Stereotyping? Check

      White Privilege? Check

      Black Privilege? Check (just like whitey, even though you deny it)

      White Supremacist? Nope, not me. But all the minorities in the world who insist on immigrating to only white nations are the real “White supremacists”. Otherwise the boatpeople would be tearing down the doors to Rwanda or Zaire or whatever third world socialist craphole is just teeming with all the benefits and glories of the culturally diverse People’s of Color Paradise.

      .

      • http://heavyarmor.wordpress.com/ Heavy Armor

        ” But all the minorities in the world who insist on immigrating to only white nations are the real “White supremacists”. ”

        White nations?

        Are you including the United States, the Provincial States of Canada, and South Africa on that list?

        Because I’m sure those places were already inhabited before you got here.

        • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

          .

          Yes, those, and others, are the places the “White Supremacists of Color” are risking drowning, rape, robbery and, in many cases, certain death to get into.

          .

          • Anonymous

            Can you be racially insensitive without being supreme of your “own” race?

          • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

            .

            Yes.

            .

      • Anonymous

        Furthermore, those “third world socialist crapholes” that you speak of were very much affected by white colonialism. Way out of the scope and context of the post, but you opened the door.

        • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

          .

          “…those “third world socialist crapholes” that you speak of were very much affected by white colonialism…” Yes, Very much so affected by colonialism and in very positive manners, too.

           But they and others, like Zaire, Detroit and Rhodesia, became said third world socialist crapholes when people of color were voted into power and instituted ‘authenticatie, affirmative action or indiginization’ policies based on Black Privilege.

          .

          • Anonymous

            And there we have it. 

            If you aren’t a white supremacist, somebody somewhere owes you an Academy Award.

          • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5K64GROAYYQ2CPKARCAUERBXI MICHAEL DEAN MILLER

            .

            Pointing out failures of black privilege hardly makes one a “supremacist” ……

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100002965779125 Ryan Malcolm Jonny

      Or maybe you are making up terms like “white privilege”.

      White people will be a small minority in every country by 2080 according to the UN predictions, “white privilege” is a joke at best, and a myth that only the uneducated believe in at worst.

  • Janedoe

    First time I’ve seen these videos, wish I could say I was shocked at some of the rude, ignorant remarks, but I’m not.  As a mother [white, and I hate that term, Irish-Italian-Slav and yes they are Very different cultures]  of a Native Indian daughter [half Cherokee] who is dark skinned and beautiful [ok yes I'm bias] I have lived with this crap all my life, remarks towards myself and remarks-behaviors towards my daughter, which are far worse because she gets it from several sides.  We had to move from a State because of the hatred, being blacklisted, etc., and yes, the rude remarks, esp the ones my daughter gets, never cease to amaze me, I’ve grown to literally hate people, sad.

    But  I would like to add, one thing, that I wish would come out in the light more and that is the issue of CLASS.  Which some separate but I find they not only overlap but that in numerous ways it’s the Class issue that is far worse, and THE one that no one wants to dare touch.  And I honestly can’t say how much of the crap we’ve been dealt is due to Class and not just Race/Multi-Cultural, and obviously, a lot of the garbage is just pure blatant patriarchal Misogyny–THAT is obvious and white women I have to say do more to uphold those pillars than anyone.  I have come to the conclusion that it comes from the conditioning of the Roman Empire-gods and all that B.C. crap [yea I hate it].  Anything for gold eh….

    my point being, Privilege is rampant in this nation and it’s not just White.  Not to minimize white privilege but just pointing out that in my limited experience I see more Class privilege that is more sinister and flat out deadly…and the most invisible to confront and I’m not talking about the middle class being pissed about paying more taxes, I’m talking about a real ignorance of POVERTY, and the hierarchy of infrastructure that is the Pillar of the whole dang pyramid.  I hear stupid remarks all the time, as an impoverished woman, such as, “why don’t you save up your monthly check to get that insurance so you can Leave your abusive Nigel and have your spine fixed”, uh, like DUH, it’s called Math, or oh, yea the utmost and those of us who have ever been caught up in the System [criminal or with any of the courts] “oh you should get counseling”, uh, ya duh….NO, I don’t NEED you to tell me I am poor or in abusive situation, I KNOW that already, what I NEED is RESOURCES, not paper lists of void numbers and a job that Pays a Living Wage, etc., etc., etc., or ‘can’t you just get on low income housing or food stamps’ Like Yea, they just hand that out like candy now don’t they—Then it’s the ‘oh well you know it’s those immigrants’ blah blah blah

    denial denial denial…meanwhile, we die, we work slave labor-sex slavery in jails-prisons, on the streets, we watch our children be locked up, forced drugged, etc etc etc…

    and what’s worse, as a White woman, well, don’t ya know, that simply doesn’t exist for us, or for Native Indian Women, the Invisible, just simply doesn’t exist–EXCEPT, for those thesis papers and briefs that the Privilege write [our paper PIMPS] when they want to Raise funds for the very crock agencies who tell us,

    as they hand us the paper useless lists, ‘you need counseling’ or the “Oh you poor dear”

    puke.  It’s the same attitude, same type of remarks that you hear in this video, so much that I feel often, like my head is turning around like the girl in the movie Exorcist–the whole dang pyramid hierarchy just needs to go, Period.

    • Anonymous

      Thank you for your comment. I’m just getting around to seeing it. I agree with you — class privilege does exist in the spectrum of who benefits and who is left to dry. I do not dismiss that. The post absolutely was about my experiences with race/gender privilege but classism is never ever dismissed, nor should the other forms of privilege maintained by the status quo. (I think in one comment I added an et al because I was going on about race, gender, sexuality, and I intended to address ableism as well.)

  • Janedoe

    re Michael, one, NO you didn’t answer the question of privilege, and I swear you must be related to my ex Nigel [soon to be ex], you sound just like him.  So, from your Throne looking down at us inferiors, allow me to explain a few things to you.  In regards to colonialism, which I will add, for the record, had a long history prior even to Europeans, going way back to B.C., the spice trade-slavery, gold trade-slavery [which has roots in Taurus Mountains, West Africa-Egypt, Persia, etc--in other words, slavery and privilege was in existence even among some African tribes-Arab tribes then, FACT, Aryan-India, China, etc], and then expanded westword [Phoenicians, Cyprus, Rome], and of course to the Engl ‘ish’ [Saxons, Celts, etc] to India [colonialism-spices/mining] and Africa, then all of Europe [the land grab] throwing the kings of old over to build up the empires of new, so to speak.  While of course assimilation via force the peasant masses, or commoners, as some would say, within their own regions under per se Lords.  Ah religion eh….and then the two main religions, both with links to the Old Kings war for that gold—goes way back, interesting history there of MINING, THOSE CROWN JEWELS….and of course one must balkanize and compartmentalize those lands and divide those Slaves, particularly language because hey, can’t let those natives get too smart now can we?  And then the English-Europeans come to America [aka religion] and loe and behold there are three, Puritans [Dutch, English], Scottish-Catholics [ole Mary didn't want to be left out] and Anglicans of English, the Jamestown and Dutch New York and Puritans-Quakers, who Interestingly couldn’t FARM because they were of the spoiled middle class merchants so the Natives taught them, or they wouldn’t have survived, FACT…and then, loe and behold, the Sugar brought over along with slaves from the Slave Coast [W Africa which interestingly is still predominantly Christian today, and oppressive as Ever], and let’s not forget the Marriage between Catholic Spain and Mayans-Aztecs of South and Central America-Mexico because hey, chocolate brought to Africa [West Africa where it's Still harvested by child slaves today] and oh, on one note, the Sugar trade they did attempt to bring over slaves from the Black Sea [Slavs] but they couldn’t survive the Malaria so they then brought over Africans….and of course That is the FOUNDATION of what we in America today, live in luxury of wealth, in comparison to the nations or worlds that we [ancestors and on going] have Raped and Pillaged since prior to 1400…of course our ancestors had already had experience at this, with the expansion of the Roman-Greek [behind the defeated Mask] empires after they had ‘supposedly’ fallen, merged with powers of the North, to look for those jewels in Ireland, France, the West, etc., and well, WELL, you know America had reports of GOLD….both North and South,

    GOLD that is for Kings, for PRIVILEGE, but alas let’s not mention that because hey why Else would BANKS have gold stored in vaults like the Tombs of Egypt?????  And Rubies [from Burma, from slaves, including forced sex slavery of females] and Diamonds [from Congo, another predominantly Christian nation], and I say Christian to reference the roots, of Christiandom, Colonialism, that destroyed HOW many pagan rural cultures of the East [slavic Russia] as well as West for that GOLD and PRIVILEGE?  Oh to be a Pharaoh eh, never mind the Blood that is spilled and lives, whole lives ruined and robbed of joy, dreams, opportunity to BE, as long as some Thug gets to sit on his/her thrown of POWER.

    And over time those colonized nations having years of erasure of language, ancient religions and ancient ways, women reduced to chattel for the STATES of EMPIRES, generational Genocides and Gendercides, to the point where they have no more memory of what they Once were…

    and then one day they throw off the yoke of colonialism and begin to rule themselves, only to find that their Learned conditioning is a mix wine, of both Ancient oppression along with Colonial, after all, the learned ones were killed off in the beginning, the women and children taught to OBEY their new ‘church’ masters, those CIVILIZED beings went to them by the Savior Aliens to be saved from their Savagery, while of course ignoring the Savagery of the white master who had no problem raping women and producing hybrids for the new Empire, obedient future generation slaves…..

    whose minds had already been colonized and poisoned, erased history and herstory, erased gods and goddesses, to be replaced with the One over all, be it Caesar or was it Jupiter?  Or Jesus? 

    and the hilarious thing is the privilege son of inheritance of that gold really believes that he is So important that his master of the Pillars will include him when the harvest time comes….ah, of course, that is why the Masters of the PTB are so intentive to hear the complaints of the working class, never mind that the Mafia systems are so entrenched in our political and court systems…that screw over the duped white ‘thinks he’s got so much power’ male every day in this nation…

    so enjoy your looking down status while it lasts, because the gold war is still on, or did you Miss that whole mining in Afghanistan of late?

    Get a clue Michael, it’s men like you, that make our enslavement so easy for them to do, them meaning, the Powers That Be.