Zurana Horton, Black Woman, Hero… SCARLET Woman

Oct 29, 2011 4 Comments by
Last Friday, 34-year-old Zurana Horton’s instincts prompted her to throw herself on top of a group of children in front of a Brownsville public school and shield them from gunfire coming from a rooftop.  As a result, Zurana was fatally shot in the head… dying instantly. Later, 18-year-old Andrew Lopez (who was arrested along with his brother) would confess to the shooting, and that he was aiming for an 11-year-old sixth grade girl (who survived injuries to her cheek and arm), he was reportedly having a dispute with over a cell-phone. Both brothers are believed to be members of a street gang.Brownsville is considered to be one of the most crime-ridden parts of Brooklyn, NY and is populated by mostly Black and Hispanic residents. Oh yes… and Zurana Horton’s selfless act left 12 (some reports say she had 13 with one on the way) children without their mother. None of the aforementioned facts about the neighborhood of Brownsville or Zurana’s numerous children should negate the fact that firing a gun from a rooftop, at an area swarming with children and innocent people, is a disturbing act that needs to be addressed (particularly when one considers New York’s strict stance on guns). Even more troubling is how the media has either seemingly ignored the story or reported it, riddled with underlying judgment… choosing to focus on the number of children Horton left behind, almost diverting attention away from the crime itself,  its victims, and Zurana’s heroism; which could seem like something out of a movie save for the accompanying comments on social media forums and Blogs about her background and the accompanying visual. Zurana Horton isn’t blond and fair, in fact her look (shown in the obscure picture making the media rounds, wearing large sunglasses and a coy smirk) belie the aesthetic most media outlets love to outline when describing women under duress. Wikipedia describes it as MWWS: Missing White Women Syndrome or Missing Pretty Girl Syndrome:

“A vernacular term used by some media and social critics to describe the seemingly disproportionate degree of coverage in television, radio, newspaper and magazine reporting of a misfortune, most often a missing person case, involving a young, attractive, white, upper-middle class (frequently blonde) woman or girl.”

And while Zurana didn’t go missing in the literal sense, the act that saved several young lives at the expense of her own, got lost in a sea of harsh criticism which included hate-filled vitriol about Brownsville and accused the slain mother of being nothing more than a “Welfare Queen” who “had no business having all those children.”  Notwithstanding the fact that no reports surfaced about Zurana Horton’s job status or lack thereof…

“My heart goes out to this brave woman and her family. I am sure she will be missed.
However, NO ONE should have 14 children. Maybe, I could see it if the parents were millionair­es, Nobel    Prize winners and Olympic athletes, but even then I would question the wisdom of their actions. This country (and the whole world) needs a population policy to DISCOURAGE people from having children, instead of subsidizin­g them.”

“I wonder how much of my tax money, both NY and federal, is going to go to supporting those 13 kids for the next several decades. Hero? She would have been a hero if she had stopped at 2, at least to the rest of society that now has to pay for their welfare, education, Medicaid, food stamps.”

“This whole thing could have been avoided if the mother had picked a healthier lifestyle. She started having children at 16 and never stopped. To be pregnant with 14 children at the age of 33 (or 34, different ages listed on different stories) is irresponsible, when she admitted that she couldn’t keep them safe. She obviously knew that it was a dangerous neighborhood and she said that she wanted to move, but she didn’t have money. But she has money to keep having kids????”

… And so the comments go.  Folks complaining about having to pay for the welfare of this woman’s children (despite her brave act) and presuming to think she was a piece of trash whose life had no value because of her environs, ethnicity, and look are no better than the young men who took her life and put other lives at risk. It’s also indicative of how little humanity some people possess, since they are able to hide behind the cloak of anonymity the Ignanet  Internet provides, spew hate and perpetuate racial stereotypes about someone they know virtually nothing about, other than the minutiae the media chooses to focus on.

Baby Mamas, Current Events, Pregnant Women, Race Matters, Single Mothers, The Media, Women

About the author

Tiff "Coffey" J is a freelance writer, short-story scribe, sporadic poet, intrepid Blogger, self-professed fire-starter, and coffee + wine lover. She has written features for print publications, has worked with professional theater company, HartBeat Ensemble, and is a contributor to other new media platforms. In short, Tiff J is just a woman who enjoys writing and drinking potent stuff. Much of her work can be found at www.coffeerhetoric.com. Follow her on Twitter: @Coffey0072
  • http://mybrowneyedview.com msladydeborah

    It is always easy to condemn someone who does not live their life according to your social and moral standards.  Especially when there is not enough details about the person to help paint a picture that fuller than her last moments of life. 

    At one time it was not unusual for a family to have large numbers of children. It was in fact the norm.  When you do not know the back story of your nation, you tend to tell the contemporary version as if it is the only way it can be. 

    Never mind that a group of children were terrorized by home grown forces.  Never mind that this woman gave her life to protect as many children as she could during a moment of living insanity.  Or that there are thireen children who have no mother now because of her protective actions.  These inconvient realities are not as important as being able to judge her as a person. That is how small minds with connected keyboads respond to tragedy.

    My prayers go out for her family and her friends for their loss of her presence.  I also have a great amount of sympathy for the neighborhood in which this took place.  It sounds like it has become a desolate place to try and thrieve. 

    The two males who were charged in this shooting are the usual suspects.  Their lack of mentaltiy and common sense is so obvious that it hurts to even think aout them being this calloused and stupid.  They will pay a price for this and so will their families.  I have no form of rationale for the need to shoot an 11 year old over a damn phone. 

    • http://twitter.com/Coffey0072 Coffey0072

      @msladydeborah I concur and could not have opined it any better myself. One thing the mass media does is plant the seeds that help prompt ignoramuses to perpetuate racial stereotypes. The fact that Zurana’s life has been trivialized and reduced to nothing more than another stereotype and as someone whose life needn’t be valued, is disgusting. The  Octomoms of the world become media darlings and get reality TV shows, charity from folks, and endorsement deals so that they can take care of their children. I think the public needs to be addressing WHY the two young men who shot at all those people, felt compelled to do what they did and HOW that type of violence in our communities can be combated. 

  • Jen

    As I mentioned before, the lack of coverage does not surprise me, seeing as she was not, as we say, a “Missing White Woman”. But the amount of SHEER HATRED directed at this woman – THIS VICTIM, THIS MURDER VICTIM – absolutely blows my mind. The sad thing is, it really shouldn’t. I would say it’s the anonymity of the internet; people feel like they can say anything and not be held responsible, but something tells me these people are just as ugly in real life.

    The whole thing is beyond tragic.

  • Flyy69

    I am saddened by the reality of what this article means for where we (they) are today, but happy that I got to discover your tremendous talent. Thank you for such a poignant and real/surreal article. I will keep the family in my prayers and will facilitate more discussion of what has not taken place in her honor. I mean things have to change or our children’s future will look bleaker than our great grand parent’s. Peace all.