MENU

Justice
Category

EricGarnerRally

ForHarriet.com’s Founder Shouldn’t March for Eric Garner Or Anyone Else

Eric Garner and the horrific way that he died have made its rounds through the media. Whether it was Spike Lee’s rendering the video in correlation to Radio Raheem to the News One article displaying what the police felt about Garner (and any other black person), there has been quite a few responses. The good thing is that many people realize that the cops were in the wrong. The bad thing is that some felt that Eric shouldn’t have “resisted arrest” (if that is what you really want to call his reactions). In short, the media has displayed what many of have felt on a positive and negative note.

But there is one reaction that has stunned me even more: it is the reaction from someone that is dismissive due to gender.

Some Won’t Be Marching For Eric Garner

Kimberly Foster wrote an “interesting” article on her website called For Harriet. The title of the article is “Why I Will Not March For Eric Garner”. Well, good for her! I’m not marching for him, either. Marching is not going to make sure these crooked cops get what they deserve. Nor is it going to protect our people from cops that will take our lives in a heartbeat. So, I agreed on the title for what it was worth.

However, her reasoning was something that was more troubling and devious than expected. Her reasoning stands on one main issue: Kimberly Foster will be “reserving my mental and emotional energy for the women, the Black women, no one will speak for” [1]. She does feel for him in the situation. However, she cannot begin to support this man when she could not “refrain from comparing the empathy shown him, particularly by Black men” while she also noted that “Black women attempt to discuss the everyday terrors we experience both in the world and at their hands” [2]. Thus, all of her issues have to do with the fact that Eric Garner is a man.

Eric Garner’s Death is Irrelevant to Any Feminist Movement

Let it be known: this is not the proper situation to bring up issues with a male dominant status quo that society brings about. Eric Garner’s death deals with the indelible fact that the police state’s predatory mentality preys upon the citizens of the US. And that predatory state has no gender preference as we all learned from the woman that was beat savagely on the side of the Los Angeles highway. I understand that women’s issues do not get the proper response; I would agree. But acting as if Eric Garner’s situation has anything to do with being a man is totally ignorant of the real issues.

Rev. Herbert Daughtry and Rev. Al Sharpton console Esaw Garner, wife of Eric Garner Photo credit: (AP Photo/John Minchillo)

Rev. Herbert Daughtry and Rev. Al Sharpton console Esaw Garner, wife of Eric Garner
Photo credit: (AP Photo/John Minchillo)

What makes me shake my head is the fact that Kimberly would want to be that dismissive toward any action because it was a man. What if this man was her father? Or better yet, what if it was her uncle, brother, or son? Would she actually dismiss the situation because they are men? Or would she actually make a statement and stand up for their deaths because they are people she cares about?

In essence, what makes this article so illogical is the fact that she is basing her experiences on women issues to affect her overall view of (Black) men. Who is to say that Eric Garner would not stand up for women’s rights? It would be one things to say “I don’t deal with Eric Garner because he did this, that, and the third”. However, it is an entire different situation to not want to partake in any form of stand-taking because of what OTHER men NOT name Eric Garner did. Labeling all men with monolithic titles and treating them as such is not going to further any feminist agenda; it will only make those women look bitterly irrational.

Then again, I can’t be surprised when the author took an external situation and internalized it. If you pay attention to her article, she had this tidbit to say:

Too many fail to recognize that the violence, psychological verbal and physical, that we direct toward each other in communal spaces reflects the violence enacted upon our bodies and minds by larger dominating structures; thus there’s an inability by many Black men to acknowledge that Black women, too, have a right to move through the world without fear–that a woman should not have to avert her eyes and quicken her pace when she encounters men in public spaces. [4]

Again, she has made a valid point that has absolutely nothing to do with Eric Garner or anything associated with this situation. Yet again, when you personalize a situation, there will be more responses about standing on a soapbox and trying to be heard rather than saying anything that solves any issues:

I’m not settling for anything less than reciprocity. If you refuse to hear our calls for help, then I cannot respond to yours. I have no desire, as a Black woman, to be placed on a pedestal, but I will not allow myself to become a footstool. Do not ask me for empathy if you are content to deny it in return. [5]

Again: at what point was this situation supposed to be personalized in this manner?

No Marching For Eric Garner At All

While ironically writing for a website named after a woman that liberated women AND men, I find it shocking that Kimberly Foster would use this situation as a personal soapbox moment for her feminist stances. We, as a people, have to realize that there is a time and place for everything. Eric Garner died due to police abusing their duties. Whether anyone should support him should not hinge on his gender. I would hope that Kimberly Foster realizes that being preyed upon is not an issue to be relegated to gender division; Harriet Tubman didn’t pick and choose, so why should she?

 

Read More
NYPD

Eric Garner, NYPD Blues and Other Cop Crap

July 24, 2014 • Justice, Race • Views: 255

I was raised on Staten Island. I won’t say I hated every minute or it because that wouldn’t be true. Every other minute. Staten Island is very Italian and very conservative. Many of those Italians hate blacks. Sorry just the way it is. Always has been. Not all but many. So a black man was

EricGarnerMurder

Eric Garner and Knowing Your Rights

July 22, 2014 • Justice, Race • Views: 905

So, my news feeds have been ablaze with the story about Eric Garner. He died because he was put in a choke hold by NY police when they tried to force him to the ground. Beyond the illegality of the said move, there is something else troubling. That troubling situation is his “past criminal

eric_garner

Eric Garner – I Can’t Breathe….Either

July 20, 2014 • Justice • Views: 1603

“I CAN’T BREATHE” After watching the video of Eric Garner being brutalized for no apparent reason, was not being violent was not out of control ….but tackled like he was trying to assassinate somebody.. “I CAN’T BREATHE” Watching yet another incident of

cracking-cards-scam_940x

“Cracking Cards” Bank Scams on the Rise on Nashville-Middle TN Campuses

June 10, 2014 • Education, Justice • Views: 4794

Nashville-Middle TN is in the midst of an economic boom. Attracting not only visitors from around the world, but corporations and new residents are being transplanted here from every corridor. But with the robust pecuniary gains come growth pains and not everyone relocating or visiting our area

rene-lima-martin-mugshot-injustice_940x

Rene Lima-Martin: Court Error Orders Free Man Back to Prison for 98yrs After Serving a 10yr Sentence

June 6, 2014 • Justice • Views: 2429

I ran into a story that I believe to be one of the most egregious injustices in recent memory. Over at The Root, they’re reporting the story of Rene Lima-Marin, who up until last January was a free man after serving a 10-year prison sentence for two armed robberies at the age of 19, some

cotton_gin_boss_940x

Lawsuit: Cotton Gin Supervisor Threatens to ‘Hang’ Black Workers Who Drink from “White People” Fountain

June 5, 2014 • Justice • Views: 4133

There has been a rash of acts of racism caught on tape lately. In recent weeks, if it isn’t a Donald Sterling audio or interview, it’s anyone from Justin Bieber, to random strippers in New York parking lots with kids in tow. If you didn’t know any better, you would think that

nigerian-school-girls (1)

Bring Back Nigeria’s 234 Missing School Girls #BringBackOurGirls

May 7, 2014 • Justice • Views: 3926

#BringBackOurGirls I’m posting this because there is a petition out that needs to be signed and it needs to be signed immediately. I will a quick copy and paste breakdown of what needs to happen: In Nigeria, over 200 girls were recently abducted from their boarding school and plans are

ryan-holle (1)

Ryan Holle, in Prison for Lending Car to a Friend?

April 25, 2014 • Justice • Views: 2498

If you are Ryan Holle, you should be pissed. About ten years ago, you lend your roommate (William Allen Jr.) your car after a party. Being white boy wasted, you go to sleep (hell, it is 5 in the morning). Meanwhile, your roommate takes 3 other men with him to rob a local marijuana dealer. Things

mike-anderson-missouri (1)

Mike Anderson and the Politics of Crime and Punishment

April 22, 2014 • Justice • Views: 2325

The problem with politics is that it involves politicians.  We routinely get politicians when what we need are leaders.  Leadership is not telling people what they want to hear in order to get elected or get attention.  True leadership is wading against the fiery currents of public opinion

miriam-carey-feat (1)

Demand Justice Now: Miriam Carey Had a Right to Life

April 12, 2014 • Justice • Views: 2797

Editor’s Note: This past week, I was able to secure an exclusive interview with attorney Eric sanders who represents the Carey family. Mr Sanders was a guest on Madness & Reality Radio and outlined the latest developments related to the investigation of the death of Miriam Carey. 

relisha-rudd-missing (1)

Young, Black, & Missing: The Disappearance of Relisha Rudd

April 7, 2014 • Justice, Media • Views: 3061

When I first saw the black and white picture of missing 8-year-old little girl, Relisha Rudd… captured with a slight smile and a faraway look… it struck a chord with me. I stared at her picture for, what seemed like, an infinite number of minutes; maybe because I have a niece around Relisha’s

rinesha-mcbride-detroit (1)

Defense Seek to Present the Lifestyle of Renisha McBride at Trial

April 4, 2014 • Justice • Views: 2415

NewsOne is reporting that defense attorney’s for Theodore Wafer who is charged with second-degree-murder for the death of Renisha McBride is seeking a very aggressive defense. McBride is the Detroit woman who was shot in the face while allegedly seeking help after a late-night car accident.

ALBUQUERQUE-police-kill-homeless-man-james-boyd (1)

Murder By Cop: Albuquerque Police Kills Homeless Man

April 3, 2014 • Justice • Views: 2605

As I watched the coverage of the latest shooting involving police officers and a person who was in no way, shape or form posing a threat to them, I realized something. Whenever someone talks about a police officer killing a person they use the term “excessive force.” Why don’t they call it

jordan-miles (1)

Jordan Miles: The Face of American Injustice

April 2, 2014 • Justice • Views: 2782

Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reports that: The eight-member jury that heard the Jordan Miles civil trial today reached a mixed verdict, finding the three officers liable for the false arrest of Mr. Miles, but it found that they did not use excessive force.   The jury awarded compensatory damages